“Trojan Kitty,” on blogging and journalism:
So, let’s get this out of the way: a blog is something between a personal diary and a newspaper. It’s, entirely incidentally, published online, as it’s the cheapest publishing mass media available. And it allows anyone to join. That’s good in some aspects, but it also lets too much noise in. There is no filter or distinction between a diary and a newspaper online. And people who have online newspapers get confused, and treat their newspaper as an online diary, and launch into personal fights with colleagues from their company and other media.
[…]
I do have a problem with every single person with a blog on this planet being piled in with the greatest journalists of the 20th and the few remaining in the 21st century; people who uncover corruption scandals, report from places of conflict, people who have the self-control to spare you the fluff, and give you the real news; wise people, who not just inform you of facts, but teach you about how this world works. And I don’t pretend or want to stand up to all the scrutiny of being a real journalist, so I’m a blogger. So are millions more. And that’s good: we’re not journalists.
And sure, just as we have journalists online, increasingly, we have bloggers in print. It is a real problem.
This debate is tearing journalism schools and newsrooms apart right now. The question is this: where is the line? I would argue that there is no clear boundary between journalism and blogging. Yes, there are some blogs that are, without a doubt, journalistic. At the same time, there are tons of blogs that aren’t even close to producing real journalism.
While I do think I perform a journalistic service here at Forkbombr, it is different than publishing via a newspaper or magazine. Here, I can write with a personal tone, and take sides on an issue. Am I reporting news and events? Yes. Am I adding commentary? Yes.
Am I a working as a journalist as I type this? Hell if I know. I’m not convinced “Trojan Kitty” does either.
I’m not sure the question even matters, as long as I stay in the gray space between the two forms of writing.
[via David Chartier]